© CC BY-FaceMePLS

Vox populi, or: democracy requires listening

Conceptually, stakeholder participation in sustainability research and governance is necessary for several reasons, including higher legitimacy and easier implementation of plans and projects. Meaningful stakeholder involvement requires taking their points of view, their values and preferences serious, and integrate them into the resulting horizontal Multicriteria Analysis MCA (a vertical MCA would use the issues and concerns suggested by stakeholders, but would weigh them top-down with the weights attributed by the decision maker). In particular the failure of monetary valuation to provide meaningful valuation instruments requires participation of a representative diversity of stakeholders in ESS research and governance to answer the question what people value, and how.

Theme

The first step of stakeholder activation is the analysis, conducted ex-ante and updated, complemented and refined perpetually on an ad-hoc basis (ad hoc analysis is also used when there was no chance for ex-ante investigation). In a first rather simplistic classification, stakeholders can be categorised as being more or less interested in the issue concerned on the one hand, and more or less influential on the other. This is the basis for developing communication and involvement strategies: Low interest stakeholders with limited influence are informed, but if their influence is high they need to be involved if anyhow possible. Interested stakeholders should be consulted even if weak, and be turned into collaborators if

Policy relevance

No major public project is implemented without ex-ante valuating different planning options, most often in terms of cost-benefit analyses. These, however, fail to take the pros and cons of different options on an equal footing: financial values tend to dominate; other values are not part of the balance sheet. To be taken into account, they would have to be monetised, and thus lose their character as non-utilitarian, non-instrumental values, as future or public values, etc. The failure of internalisation requires other value attributing mechanism, and participation of a representative diversity of stakeholders is the best option a democracy has to offer.

Although conceptually seemingly easy, reaching the desired level of engagement for the desired time span can be a wicked problem – successful participation depends on the specific socio-cultural context and requires different means and modes of participation during different project phases.

A minimum condition is to understand the reasons for engagement (or its absence), and the potential benefits the stakeholders expect (or miss). This usually requires not only benefitting from the results of a project they had no influence on, but rather the need to take their demands into account, specifying, modifying and changing the project. For research projects, that is the core of transdisciplinarity, and for other projects like infrastructure development, it should be considered as self-explaining in a democratic society.

Specific contribution by SERI

SERI and its staff members have been involved in transdisciplinary research including the active involvement of stakeholders for more than 20 years now. In several major projects SERI coordinated and organised, or contributed to the stakeholder participation processes, organised stakeholder fora and consultative groups. We do so based on the experience not only from the project organisers’ side, but also based on our experience in working with environmental and sustainable consumption NGOs, religious groups, trade unions, etc.: knowing both sides we weigh their concerns equally, and communicate concerns and hopes between the parties involved.

Other areas of activity:

Biodiversity

Biodiversity loss, the most significant transgression of the planetary boundaries so far, is going...

Read more

Strong sustainable consumption

Where can households make a difference to reduce the environmental aspect of their every day life?...

Read more

Environmental justice

The access to a healthy environment and to natural resouces is rather unevenly distributes between...

Read more

Resource efficiency and demateralisation

The reduction of natural resource use – in terms of materials, energy and land area – for...

Read more

Degrowth, labour and reproduction

Work and ecology are policy issues highly relevant on the agenda for both the EU as a whole and all...

Read more

Ecosystem services

Ecosystem services ESS are providing the benefits humans derive from nature. Many services are at...

Read more

Stakeholder activation

Vox populi, or: democracy requires listening. Conceptually, stakeholder participation...

Read more

Science-Policy Interface

“Truth speaks to power, and power implements” is still how many scientists understand their role (if...

Read more

Publications for "Stakeholder activation":

Förster, J., Barkmann, J., Fricke, R., Hotes, S., Kleyer, M., Kobbe, S., Kübler, D., Rumbaur, C., Siegmund-Schultze, M., Seppelt, R., Settele, J., Spangenberg, J.H., Tekken, V., Vaclavik, T., Wittmer, H.

Ecology and Society 20(3): 31 (2015)

Assessments of ecosystem services (ES), that aim at informing decisions on land management, are increasing in number around the globe. Despite selected success stories, evidence for ES information being used in decision making is weak, partly because ES...

Read more